Index | Search | Home | Table of Contents

Clement, C.R., R.M. Manshardt, J. DeFrank, F. Zee, and P. Ito. 1993. Introduction and evaluation of pejibaye (Bactris gasipaes) for palm heart production in Hawaii. p. 465-472. In: J. Janick and J.E. Simon (eds.), New crops. Wiley, New York.

Introduction and Evaluation of Pejibaye (Bactris gasipaes) for Palm Heart Production in Hawaii

Charles R. Clement, Richard M. Manshardt, Joseph DeFrank, Francis Zee, and Philip Ito*


  1. SELECTION OF PEJIBAYE FOR PALM HEART PRODUCTION
    1. Quality Distinctions
    2. Precocity and Yield Distinctions
  2. THE UNITED STATES IMPORT MARKET
  3. SUITABILITY OF HAWAII
    1. A Large Tourist Market for Exotics
    2. Excellent Environmental Conditions
    3. An Active Diversified Agriculture Sector
  4. THE INTRODUCTION PROGRAM
    1. The USDA Project
    2. The CAPE Project
  5. REFERENCES
  6. Fig. 1
  7. Fig. 2

Hawaiian agriculture has always been based upon "new crop" introductions. The first Hawaiians brought their Pacific crop complex with them, which included coconut (Cocos nucifera L.), breadfruit [Artocarpus altilis (Sol. ex Park) Fosb.], banana and plantains (Musa spp), sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum L.), taro [Colocasia esculenta (L.) Schott] and other minor crops (Lebot in press). With the arrival of European colonists in 1778, a new period of crop introductions began. Among the most important were pineapple [Ananas comosus (L.) Merril], papaya (Carica papaya L.), macadamia nuts (Macadamia integrifolia Maiden & Betche), guava (Psidium guajava L.), coffee (Coffea arabica L.), ginger root (Zingiber oficinale Roscoe), plus numerous other fruits, vegetables, flowers, and livestock (HASS 1990). The continued viability of Hawaiian agriculture depends fundamentally upon research directed at raising yields through improved agronomy and genetics, lowering production costs, and introducing new specialty crops with which Hawaii can develop a production and marketing edge.

Among the options is pejibaye (Bactris gasipaes Kunth), also known as the peach palm (Hamilton 1987; Roecklein and Leung 1987; Clement 1990). The pejibaye is the Neotropic's only domesticated palm and is well suited to modern agriculture. Its palm heart has potential as a gourmet fresh vegetable. The palm heart is composed of the tender leaves that originate in and grow from the palm meristem and are consumed before they expand and green. Palm heart can supply both the tourist's desire for exotic foods and west coast markets for exotic vegetables. Its multiple potentials in modern agriculture have been examined by Mora Urpí (1984) and Clement and Mora Urpí (1987).

The pejibaye fruit has four uses: cooked fruit for human consumption, flour for bread and confectionaries, vegetable oil, and animal ration. Its unique flavor and texture, however, is unknown to the public outside of tropical America and would require a concerted marketing effort to promote acceptance.

The palm heart, in contrast, is well known and its consumption is expanding rapidly worldwide (Mora Urpí et al. 1991). Palm heart production and canning is already a rapidly growing industry in Latin America. The pejibaye palm heart has been on international markets since 1978 and is expanding in market share in both Europe and the United States (Mora Urpí et al. 1991). The United States currently (1989) imports 2000 t of canned palm heart (up from 900 t in 1980), valued at $4.5 million, of which 700 t is from pejibaye (U.S. Dept. Commerce 1990).

The palm heart market is based upon a processed product, which, although popular, has limited culinary potential because it is pre-cooked in a slightly salty, strongly acidic solution (Quast and Bernhardt 1978). Nonetheless, the value of current world trade in canned palm hearts is estimated to be close to $50 million. World consumption is much greater, because humid tropic populations consume the bulk of locally available fresh palm heart. Brazil, for example, is both the largest producer and largest exporter (70% of world trade): in 1988, 100,000 t of fresh palm heart were produced, but only 9,500 t were exported (Coradin and Clement 1989). Brazil's production is based upon the palm Euterpe oleracea, which occurs in large natural populations in the Amazon River estuary. E. oleracea has several characteristics that limit its potential for the fresh market. The most important of these is the presence of enzymes that discolor the palm heart upon contact with air.

The popularity of fresh palm heart in Latin America suggests that a strong demand can be created for this product in countries that currently know only the canned product. The pejibaye is ideally suited for the fresh market, because its palm heart does not discolor upon cutting and has good shelf life. Production of pejibaye for the fresh market could permit higher returns to growers. This includes the Hawaiian farmer, who has excellent growing conditions, an efficient agro-industrial infrastructure, and a large tourist market in search of novel foods.

In this paper we will discuss the commercial potential of pejibaye, the current American palm heart market, and the role that Hawaii can play in the crop's further expansion and commercialization.

SELECTION OF PEJIBAYE FOR PALM HEART PRODUCTION

There are several thousand palm species distributed around the tropical world. All have edible hearts. Perhaps 100 species have hearts that are large enough to be commercialized and most are used in local cuisines. Within this group of large palms, there are some with hearts that are slightly sweet, others that are bland, and a few that are bitter. The pejibaye is a member of the sweet group, as are many other well known species of the Cocosoide sub-family, including the coconut (Cocos nucifera L.) and the African oil palm (Elaeis guineensis Jacq.). As a domesticate, it is adapted to agroecosystems and grows rapidly. These traits, combined with its caespitose (multistemmed) growth habit and non-discoloring palm heart, are its major advantages over other palm heart species.

In spite of these advantages, international trade in palm hearts is based upon the genus Euterpe, of South and Central America. Brazil started exporting E. edulis in the 1950s (Renesto and Vieira 1977). This agro-industry was based upon extraction of wild palms from the Atlantic forests of southern Brazil and soon decimated the wild populations, since it is a single-stemmed species with very slow growth rates. The industry then shifted to the estuary of the Amazon River to exploit E. oleracea, a smaller statured, caespitose species (Calzavara 1972). The majority of Brazil's exports (>90%) are now derived from this species, although Brazilians still consider E. edulis to be the premier palm heart (Coradin and Clement 1989).

Quality Distinctions

Ferreira et al. (1982a, b) compared E. edulis and pejibaye palm hearts, and M.L.A. Bovi (Instituto Agronomico de Campinas pers. commun.) and her colleagues provided information on E. oleracea. Fig. 1 presents four important compositional characteristics that differ amongst the three species. Tannins in the Euterpe are double those in pejibaye, which explains the slight bitterness of the Euterpe (Ferreira et al. 1982b). Total sugars in pejibaye are triple those in the Euterpe, which explains the sweetness of the pejibaye (Ferreira et al. 1982b). Most important, the levels of the polyphenoloxidase and peroxidase enzymes, which cause the rapid tissue discoloration in Euterpe spp., are nearly absent in pejibaye (Ferreira et al. 1982a).

The pejibaye palm heart is yellower than that of E. edulis (Ferreira et al. 1982a), a slight disadvantage in a market accustomed to a bone-white product. The texture of pejibaye is somewhat firmer than that of E. edulis, due to slightly lower water and higher fiber contents.

A Brazilian test panel accustomed to E. edulis found the pejibaye acceptable (7.0 vs 8.5 for E. edulis, on a 1 to 9 scale) (Ferreira et al. 1982a). Several restaurant chefs in Ubatuba, Sao Paulo, Brazil (in the heart of E. edulis' distribution), were extremely enthusiastic about pejibaye's culinary potential after evaluating this new product in direct comparison with E. edulis.

Precocity and Yield Distinctions

Of the three palm heart species discussed here, only the pejibaye is a full domesticate. E. edulis is a native of the nearly extinct Atlantic forest of coastal Brazil and requires moderate shade during its early development (Bovi et al. 1988). E. oleracea is a native of the, floodplain swamps of the eastern Amazon River basin, where it occurs in large, nearly monospecific stands (Peters et al. 1989). The pejibaye is native to the plateaus of western Amazonia and was domesticated in Native American agroecosystems (Clement 1988).

E. edulis must be planted with light to moderate shade during the first 3 to 5 years, and suffers high plant mortality during establishment (Bovi et al. 1988). At very high plant densities (6,666 and 10,000 plants/ha), yields are excellent (2.9 and 2.5 t/ha, respectively), but the palm hearts are small (200 to 250 g). At lower densities, yields are lower (1 to 2 t/ha), but palm hearts are larger (to 600 g) (Bovi et al. 1988). Harvest size is only attained at 6 to 8 years and, since the plants have only one stem, the plantation must be replanted (Bovi et al. 1988). Annual yields, in uneven aged natural stands, are therefore estimated at 0.5 t/ha (2.9 t/ha after 6 years).

E. oleracea grows faster than E. edulis, attaining harvest size in 4 to 6 years, both in its natural, nutrient rich ecosystem and in plantation (Bovi et al. 1988). This species should be planted in light shade, which can be removed within a year. Compared to E. edulis, plant mortality during establishment is low in humid soils (Calzavara 1972), but high on plateau soils in Amazonia (Gomes 1983). Yields are similar to those of E. edulis and show similar size to density trends. Because it is a caespitose palm, management for continuous cropping is possible (Calzavara 1972). Each clump yields another palm heart after 18 to 24 months (Bovi et al. 1988). Annual yields of E. oleracea are estimated at 1.4 t/ha after the first harvest.

Pejibaye can be planted in full sun, after light shade in the nursery. If correctly handled, it does not suffer plant mortality during establishment. In agroecosystems, it grows rapidly and responds readily to applications of fertilizers and other inputs, and attains harvest size in 18 to 30 months (Mora Urpí 1984). Yields and size to density trends are similar to the Euterpe species. Like E. oleracea, it is caespitose and is managed for continuous cropping and each clump yields another palm heart after 9 to 15 months (Clement et al. 1988). Annual yields are 2 t/ha after the first harvest in Costa Rica (Mora Urpí et al. 1991).

Although Brazil has a strong Euterpe tradition, there is currently strong interest in planting pejibaye in high density monocultures, because of the above mentioned advantages. In Acre state, 300+ ha are in production (A. Vieira, BONAL SA pers. commun.). Numerous agribusinessmen from Sao Paulo, Espirito Santo, and Bahia are starting to plant and have created an over-heated market for seeds of spineless pejibaye. The only national producer of these seeds, located in Manaus, received requests for 3+ million seed in 1989, but could only supply 0.5 million. Recent (1991) Brazilian government environmental regulations require management plans for extraction of Euterpe species from natural stands. This new factor will probably encourage palm heart agribusinesses to plant more pejibaye.

THE UNITED STATES IMPORT MARKET

Compared to the French import market, the United States palm heart market is still very small, consuming 2,000 t in 1989. This is equivalent to an annual consumption of only 8 g/person, versus about 100 g/person in France.

In the United States market, imports of E. oleracea have been extremely erratic over the last two decades. In 1977, the Organization of American States reported poor quality control as the major factor limiting imports of Euterpe palm hearts. As Mora Urpí et al. (1991) explain, exploitation of wild populations of E. oleracea by poorly trained harvesters results in an extremely variable product, frequently too fibrous or discolored for canning (Quast and Bernhardt 1978). These defects are not always handled adequately in the canning plants, and fibrous or discolored palm hearts are occasionally marketed. This lack of rigorous quality control in the canning plant has not been addressed by most Brazilian exporters to date, so that considerable volatility can continue to be expected.

Pejibaye palm heart entered the American market in 1978. Since then it has continued to expand its market share, except in 1988, when it contracted as a result of Brazil's introduction of a minimum price for its palm heart, which increased prices for all tropical American palm hearts and lowered demand. The current Brazilian government eliminated this price support in 1990. In 1989, Costa Rican pejibaye accounted for 22.5% of the domestic US market, versus only 3% in 1982. During this period, the American palm heart import market more than doubled in size

Fig. 2 presents the palm heart imports observed during the 1980s in the American market. Euterpe imports are extremely volatile, but did not previously have competition from another high quality palm heart. This new factor may be fatal for the Brazilian Euterpes, unless the Brazilian exporters start practicing good quality control. The pejibaye trend, based only upon Costa Rican exports, is strongly upward. If the Brazilian Euterpe exporters do not institute quality control and Costa Rican exports continue to expand, Fig. 2 suggests that pejibaye could become the major palm heart in the American market by the late 1990s.

SUITABILITY OF HAWAII

Hawaii is the only state in the United States with a tropical climate to grow this tropical crop commercially. There are three other reasons for being optimistic that Hawaii can develop a successful market for its pejibaye palm heart.

A Large Tourist Market for Exotics

Hawaii's annual tourist population is 2 to 3 times larger than its permanent population of 1 million. This transient population, obviously wealthy enough to make the trip, is searching for, or at least receptive to exotic experiences, especially exotic foods. For the Asians, who make up a large fraction of the tourist population, western style foods are in demand, while for the Americans and Europeans, the Asian foods are an attraction. The pejibaye palm heart can provide an exotic touch to any meal and will be perfectly acceptable in the cuisine of both hemispheres.

An ideal way to penetrate this market is through the chef's clubs in Honolulu and on the Island of Hawaii. The imagination of these master chefs in developing new culinary uses for fresh palm heart could be essential. Through their restaurants, an initial test of the tourist and local markets can be made.

Excellent Environmental Conditions

The Hawaiian islands contain a wide array of soil and climatic conditions, some of which are ideal for pejibaye. Many areas have been in sugarcane, and these farmers are seeking new crop options. Preliminary observations suggest that yields close to those currently attained in Latin America will be possible.

An Active Diversified Agriculture Sector

In 1989, 17% of Hawaii's agricultural hectarage (excluding pastures) was occupied by diversified agriculture, defined in Hawaii as excluding sugarcane and pineapple. The diversified sector produced 37% of Hawaii's nearly $500 million dollar agricultural income (excluding livestock) (HASS 1990). Both the agricultural community and the state realize that Hawaiian agriculture must diversify to survive in the face of rapidly rising land prices (driven by tourism and urbanization) and competition from abroad.

The state of Hawaii recently initiated a crop diversification program, coordinated by the Council for Agricultural Product Expansion (CAPE), an advisory group to the Governor's Agricultural Coordinating Committee. The University of Hawaii and an active agribusiness sector are also involved. Continued diversification will depend upon the imagination, energy and cooperation of these three groups.

THE INTRODUCTION PROGRAM

The University of Hawaii and private individuals have introduced pejibaye into the islands occasionally during the last several decades. The most notable introductions were carried out from the late 1960s to the late 1970s by Richard A. Hamilton, Department of Horticulture, who introduced pejibaye as a fruit crop. The pejibaye's rather starchy texture and uniquely nutty sweet flavor limited its acceptance. Furthermore, the initial introductions were of spiny stemmed plants and did not attract much attention from the diversified agricultural community in Hawaii.

In the early 1980s, the United States Agency for International Development sponsored a series of pan-Amazonian germplasm explorations that collected and mapped a considerable portion of the genetic diversity inherited from the Native Americans in the Neotropics (Clement and Coradin 1988). In the final report of that project, Mora Urpí and Clement (1988) classified and mapped 8 landraces of pejibaye and numerous hybrid populations. Clement and Mora Urpí (1987) and Clement (1988) proposed improvement programs for pejibaye's five major potential uses based upon different landraces and hybrid populations.

The spineless hybrid population found at Yurimaguas and the associated Pampa Hermosa landrace were suggested for use in the palm heart improvement program, combined with spineless germplasm available from the Benjamin Constant population of the Putumayo landrace and the San Carlos population of the Central American complex (Clement et al. 1988). With this germplasm identified and available from several Latin American germplasm collections, a new introduction of pejibaye into Hawaii was organized.

The USDA Project

A project designed to introduce pejibaye for palm heart is now financed by a USDA Special Research Grant for Tropical Agriculture and carried out by the Department of Horticulture, University of Hawaii, on the island of Oahu, in collaboration with the USDA National Clonal Germplasm Repository and the University of Hawaii Beaumont Research Center, both on the island of Hawaii.

Open-pollinated progenies from each of the two major Amazonian spineless populations identified above have been introduced. Seed from Benjamin Constant and Yurimaguas included both selected and non-selected spineless genotypes from the collections of the National Research Institute for Amazonia--INPA, of Brazil's National Research Council. Additional germplasm from San Carlos, Costa Rica, is expected in 1992. This germplasm will provide a wide genetic base from which to identify promising accessions for the diverse Hawaiian agroecosystems.

This germplasm will be maintained at two sites, the National Clonal Germplasm Repository's Waiakea station, at Hilo, on the island of Hawaii, and the University of Hawaii's Waimanalo Experiment Station, on the island of Oahu. The environmental conditions at Hilo are characterized by thin soils of recent volcanic origin. The climate provides abundant rainfall and lacks a pronounced dry season, although any dry spell on these shallow soils can become serious, if prolonged for more than a week or two. Environmental conditions at Waimanalo are unique in Hawaii, with a rich loamy soil, abundant rainfall (October-March) with a pronounced dry season and strong trade winds. Nonetheless, pejibaye does well there, if sheltered from the wind.

Progeny x density trials are being planted with germplasm from each base population. The densities used are 3,333, 5,000, and 6,666 plants/ha. Current commercial density in Costa Rica is 5,000 plants/ha, but larger or smaller palm hearts may be required for the fresh market. After the first harvest, the plants will be managed to have two stems each, thus doubling densities.

The progeny trials are located in environments representative of major Hawaiian agricultural zones. The choice of sites provides information that can be extrapolated to almost any likely plantation site for pejibaye in Hawaii, Latin America, or elsewhere in the Pacific basin.

Growth and yield data will be collected at 6 month intervals. This will permit timely evaluation of pejibaye populational adaptation to the conditions chosen and will permit early modification of cultural practices to enhance growth, should this prove necessary. Several physiological parameters of interest in plant improvement and agronomy will be estimated from the growth and yield data (Corley 1983). Genotype-environment interactions will be examined to improve the extrapolation of results from this experiment to other areas.

The CAPE Project

The costs of installing and maintaining a hectare of pejibaye plantation for palm heart in Hawaii were estimated as part of a feasibility study. In general, this crop option looks promising, but the study identified the high maintenance cost of weed control as a problem. In Latin America, most pejibaye is hand-weeded, since the herbicides used there have suppressed growth and reduced palm heart quality (Mora Urpí, Univ. Costa Rica pers. commun.).

Yet, Hawaiian agriculture depends upon herbicides for weed control, as labor is both scarce and expensive (DeFrank 1990). The Environmental Protection Agency regulations are constantly narrowing the number of herbicides that can be used in the United States and registration for new crops is becoming increasingly difficult and expensive. Consumers are also demanding less pesticide residues in their foods and are willing to pay more for products produced in herbicide-free environments (DeFrank 1990). To evaluate the effect of herbicides on pejibaye in Hawaii and look at "organic" alternatives, a second project was designed and approved by the CAPE. The major points to be evaluated include:

Three herbicides (Gramoxone, Goal, and Surflan) will be tested with pejibaye at commercial density (5,000 plants/ha). A non-bearing EPA approval will be requested for the most efficient.

Ground covers, including Desmodium ovalifolium, D. heterophyllum, Arachis pintoi, and Cassia rotundifolia, will be tested with pejibaye at the same commercial density. These species are prostrate non-climbers and relatively shade-tolerant. D. ovalifolium has given good results at pejibaye fruiting densities (400 plants/ha) in Brazil and Peru, but has not been tested at palm heart densities. If one or more of these species forms a good cover and does not compete with the crop, it will help control weeds, as well as offer the other agroecological advantages expected from cover crops (DeFrank 1990).

Black plastic mulch sheets have a long tradition in Hawaii as a crop establishment aid for controlling early weed growth. Recent advances in plastic technology allow mulch to remain in the field for up to five years for efficient weed control (DeFrank and Easton-Smith 1990). This mulch will be combined with both the herbicides and the ground covers and evaluated as an aid in further reducing costs.

REFERENCES


*The authors thank Dr. Marilene L.A. Bovi, Instituto Agronômico de Campinas, for information about E. oleracea.

Fig. 1. Four important quality characteristics of palm heart species. Note that B. gasipaes has no oxidases to discolor the fresh palm heart.

Fig. 2. Imports of canned palm hearts from Brazil and Costa Rica during the period 1983-1990. Small amounts are also imported from 10 to 15 other countries but rarely amount to more than 10% of the total. Note the extreme volatility of the Brazilian product.
Last update April 24, 1997 aw